are you honest? (103). In addition, you state that Hamlet drops hints such as Where is your father in his conversation with Ophelia to show that he recognizes that he is being watched. Therefore, he must break off all ties with her. One moment he says 'I did love you once', the next 'I loved you not'. After having already witnessed his uncles promiscuity, which has corrupted Hamlets view of love, and subsequently declaring frailty thy name is woman about his mother, it is not surprising that Hamlet acts strange and unkindly towards the woman who represented love and its innocence to him, Ophelia. Hamlet showed Ophelia that he did not trust her and continued to question her about her honesty and her fairness. In other words I think he refuses to marry her because he is against women and does not want to become a sinner. When Hamlet speaks to Ophelia his tone is very destructive and abhorrent since he advices her, get thee to a nunnery(iii.ii.118). Polonius feels that Hamlet is merely deeply depressed because of his break up with Ophelia. "You should not have believ'd meI loved you not." This scene shows that Hamlet feels scornful towards everyone, even himself. Hamlet is frustrated at Ophelia after she brings up the idea of marriage. This is all built up frustration that Hamlet seems to have towards his mother because of unfaithfulness and committing incest. Rather, he says The fair Ophelia! In 3:1- Perhaps, this is why when Hamlet explodes on Ophelia; he claims she should enter a nunnery rather than become breeder of sinners. Listening to Polonius, Ophelia returns love tokens to Hamlet, which is what sparks this outburst. She cherished the love letters he sent her and kept them as mementos. A discussion of whether or not Hamlet loved Ophelia in Act 3, Scene 1 of myShakespeare'sHamlet. He is telling Ophelia to become a nun and not to bread, for if she does theyll be sinners. The first is that I do not believe his pessimistic view of mankind has anything to do with his shattered naivety. Hamlet's tirade against Ophelia and women in general stems from his original anger towards his mother. At this point in the play, he has reached a point at which we have trouble making sense of his actions. He is trying to claim that he will not fall in love with her because he doesnt want to be a man with a unfaithful wife. According to you, he should have aimed his insults directly at Ophelia, not at all women. If Hamlet really loved Ophelia this is self-destructive behavior, and this act doesnt even convince Claudius to suspect him less. After noticing how deceitful his mother Queen Gertrude he assumed that all women in general are the same in which doing so insults Ophelia in many ways. Claudius has the most cynical belief as he thinks that Hamlet is not insane or lovesick but rather deeply troubled by something far more serious and dangerous. Re: GolemI found your analysis of this scene to be a bit problematic:You say that Hamlet is telling her she's just as bad as he is - where does he say that? He may recognize that there comes a point where one stops simulating madness and becomes truly insane, and perhaps he is protecting Ophelia from herself. Hamlet orders Ophelia to go to nunnery and asks why wouldst thou be a breeder of sinners? He wants her to become a nun so that she may not bear children. So the real question is what exactly is Ophelia and Hamlets true relationship? and more. Hamlet gets unbelievably angry at Ophelia's betrayal here that, to me at least, his behavior can only be described as venomous. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Hamlet Post #6: What is your reading of Hamlet and Ophelias relationship in Act 3 Scene 2? From the beginning of their conversation Hamlet kept on questioning her loyalty and putting hints of how her beauty is that of an allusion to all thats happening around her. His affections do not that way tend But Polonius states But yet I do believe the origin and commencement of his grief sprung from neglected love Hamlets words have had the desired affect in that they have kept Claudius and Polonius perplexed and none the wiser to his true intentions. After Ophelia has gone, Claudius agonizes over her madness and over the stir created by the return of an angry Laertes. "What are some pieces of evidence that prove Hamlet didn't really love Ophelia?" Hamlet uses Ophelia as an outlet to express his anger and disgust to woman in general. He goes so far as to command her to "get thee to a nunnery," implying that she has no place with him as he cannot succumb to the corrupting "wiles" of women. It would be expected that after he was interrupted he would feel immediate anger and annoyance. For instance, when he tells Ophelia to go to a nunnery, he is really directing the statement to his mother. Another instance of Hamlet trying to play around with Ophelias emotions is when Hamlet tells Ophelia you should not have believed me I loved you not (lines 115-116). Shakespeare's tragic hero Hamlet's fatal flaw is his failure to act immediately to kill Claudius, his uncle and murderer of his father. In fact Hamlet did indeed love her once but her actions have made that love diminish. Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Hamlet seeks to discern if Ophelia is genuine or deceitful like other women who God has given you one face and you make yourselves another I believe that Hamlets treatment of Ophelia is due to a combination of both tactic and emotion. While what you said about him viewing it from a philosophical standpoint is true, what would that specifically make him react so cruelly to Ophelia, his (former) love? eNotes Editorial, 31 Jan. 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-evidence-prove-hamlet-didnt-love-ophelia-557073. Maybe Ophelia was in denial and made it seem like he was head over heels when in the end he is resentful towards humans. Ophelia enters singing about death and betrayal. Ophelia responds by mourning the type of person Hamlet was before. He lost his father, saw his mother and uncle get married, and now his love is leaving him. It is clear that he's hurting Ophelia, but is more likely beacause of his mental state at the time of their encounter. )I will concede that perhaps pushing Ophelia away to protect her is not his sole purpose, but I think it's definitely part of his plan. Peach4life, I do not understand how you criticize a director with a reputation of respect and greatness such as Zeffirelli. What means your lordship? While he tells us that he is constructing a plan in which he pretends to act insane, his words lead us to think that he is in no way pretending. And then he insults her father: "Let the doors be shut upon him, that he may play the fool nowhere but in's own house." Well this information seems completely false after reading Act three scene one since Hamlet acts really harsh towards Ophelia. Hamlets greeting towards Ophelia following his soliloquy in regards was rather surprising. Firstly, Polonius and Laertes have both heard that Hamlet has been chasing after Ophelia and counsel her to avoid his love - as he, as the heir to the throne, is way out of her social. November 25, 2014 With 22 comments Hamlet Post #7: A tragic figure has to be active in bringing on problems, or has to be active in resisting a situation. A few lines later, however, he claims I loved you not. It is difficult to believe that Hamlet is merely toying with Ophelias emotions, because the reader is well aware that Hamlet did truly love Ophelia before his bouts of madness. Hamlets behavior towards Ophelia is very cruel. Hamlet'sinteraction with Ophelia fits in with his experiences with Claudius and his mother, and illustrates his increasing mistrust of everyone around him. In this scene Hamlet purposely pushes Ophelia away to save her; he wants to ensure that she won't be hurt emotionally when Hamlet finally goes ahead with his plan, and that she won't be in trouble for having a connection with a conspirator. He believesor claims to believethat women are inherently devious and untrustworthy; that if Ophelia should marry then she'll almost certainly cheat on her husband. After this scene Claudius and Polonius are still unaware of the reason behind Hamlets insanity and attribute it to different causes. RE: Mare flareI disagree (like yosh29) that Hamlet's orginal intention was to make Ophelia think he is crazy in order to prevent her from future pain. Ophelia slightly insults Hamlet by saying he wasnt as nice as the presents he gave her and he responded asking her if she was good or beautiful. VDOM DHTML tml>. He starts to insult her about how she is a whore and he didnt loved her anymore. For instance, Ophelia encounters Hamlet telling him to take back all of the gifts that he has ever given her. (1) Hamlet was at one time sincerely and ardently in love with Ophelia. ", Latest answer posted December 25, 2020 at 10:45:45 AM. It is possible to suggest that Ophelia is simply a character added to enhance plot development, or to act as a red herring, both for Polonius and for the audience.Whether or not Hamlet is mad is a completely separate issue that I will not deal with. "Where does Hamlet repeatedly tell Ophelia to go?" Same thing with Ophelia but how he shows his affection is by telling her get thee to a nunnery. This meant that even though Hamlet doesnt want to marry Ophelia he doesnt want her to marry anyone else. After Hamlet tells Ophelia that he never loved her, he tells Ophelia. I believe this because Hamlet had just proclaimed that he would be pretending insanity and because he had also previously displayed his fondness of taking advantage of his guise by saying anything he liked without consequence. Ophelia's reply to Laertes here implies that she is defending her relationship with Hamlet thus showing her strong bond with him and her love for him. No wise man, he says, should ever marry, as he should know that woman could only be his downfall and/or a weak and unworthy companion. Then he insist she goes to a nunnery. Aware that they are being watched, Hamlet stages his own response and argues that he gave her nothing and that he has never loved her. Cite textual evidence assupport. Despite his seemingly rational appearance, he automatically takes his anger over his mother's marriage and applies it to all woman. Hamlet denies having done so, going further to imply that Ophelia was foolish in having believed that he loved her. "My words fly up, My thoughts remain below. This is hinted to when he makes several references, such as the apparently random Wheres your father? Towards the end of their encounter, Hamlet suddenly mentions Ophelias paintings, saying that God hath given you on face, and you make yourselves another. This suggests the quality of duplicity, of deception, a theme which is also important in the play.Polonius, in his suspicion that Hamlet is mad over his love for Ophelia, is thus far portrayed as a fool, unaware of the circumstances, plotting as he is, unknowingly, with the murderer of King Hamlet. What evidence in this play proves Hamlet's love for Ophelia? She didnt think Hamlet would dismiss all women because of this, especially herself (who Hamlet has a relationship with). Claudius reminds Laertes that they have a plan to kill Hamlet. 64). Re:Tag829I dont believe you can take what Polonius and Laretes say about Hamlet too seriously, they are clearly biased fromthe beginning. If this is the way you want to look at this, how do you qualify Hamlet's numerous comments to the evilness of his uncle and Polonius? When Hamlet says "You should not have believ'd meI loved you not," it shows that even Hamlet's first innocent love must be treated like all women because she is no different. Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. One could argue that Ophelia would have been so regardless of Hamlet 's difficulties: She was already in . Am I missing something? It's fitting, coming from such a rational guy, to think along these lines. Much of what Hamlet says can be taken as an attack to his mother and to Claudius. RALPH: Yes, that's not easy to understand. While reading the conversation between Hamlet and Ophelia in act three scene the phrase Hamlet states to Ophelia get thee to a nunnery appears as pattern that tends to repeat in Hamlets lines. He attitude changes right away when she brings you the topic about gifts, letters, and especially marriage. Hamlet enacts how he thinks of Ophelia by stating, for wise men know well enough what monsters you make of them (Act 3 Scene 1 Line 133). This was a symbol of unrequited love , since he felt she wasnt return any affections for him .ophelias actions where performed when Hamlet was in a time where he was very sensitive since he was in grief for his fathers murder and disspointment in women . He cannot tell anyone his plan, not even his former love, Ophelia, because he cannot trust anyone. He thinks of it as a better alternative than the idea of her "bearing more sinners.". Lets face It in his soliloque he was contemplating whether he should commit suicide or live; if any of us were in his shoes wouldnt we snap judgment for angry words at anyone who came up to us immediately after? Before reading Act 3 scene 1 we had little information on how Ophelia and Hamlet are in love with each other. He has fused the imaginary with reality. Hamlet tells Ophelia, Get thee to a nunnery. Hamlet was too harsh because even when he does believe her, he also belittled her making her seem as if she is not as beautiful and honest; power of beauty will sooner transform honesty from what it is to a bawd than the force of honesty can translate beauty into his likeness (110-111). The other layer to the argument is that he would like to confuse Claudius and Polonius, make them think he is obsessed with Opehlia rather than revenge. What are some quotes from Hamlet that prove Hamlet and Ophelia's love for one another. Out of the blue, as when Hamlet asked Rosencrantz and Guildenstern if they were "sent for", Hamlet asks Ophelia, "Where's your father?" Are you honest? I believe that there is a lot of evidence arguing that Hamlet never loved Ophelia and that he was just using her. By Act 3, scene 1, Hamlet has descended into the straits of madness. The play begins by showing us the Ghost appearing in front of several witnesses, who see it and discuss it among themselves, so we know from the outset that the Ghost is not simply a figment of Hamlet's imagination. He is trying to contradict himself in his words to convince her that he has gone mad. Both Hamlet and Ophelia are like leaves in a tornado to a great extent. Why does Hamlet tell Ophelia to go "to a nunnery" and what does he give as his reason? Continued frustration and anger occurs, as they continue to converse until Ophelia brings up the idea of marriage. He might have been mean and harsh to Ophelia because he is afraid of the future that holds what he doesnt know it. Just because he is associating the 2 ideas does not mean he has to respond in that wat to Ophelia - his suicidal thoughts might be independent from his alleged madness. The poor girl! He might also be trying to get away from her because of his revenge..when taking revenge, you also have to think about the people you love and those around you because once your life is in danger, the people around you will also be in danger. It is also possible that he simply does not want any distractions from his vengeful plan, and the beautiful Ophelia is a distraction in his mind that he seeks to be rid of. These unclear lines help delude the track to the King but make all the more clear to the reader the path Hamlet has set for himself. Presumably, Hamlet expressed affection, possibly even feelings of love, to Ophelia prior to the timeframe of the story, as she in Act 3, Scene 1, lines 92-94 states that she has "remembrances" of his to give back, later saying he gave them to her with "words of so sweet breath composed." The Ghost is one of the great mysteries of Hamlet . Even though he hates his mother for marrying Claudius he still have feelings for her. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 1:33:52 PM. Hamlet. On two points no reasonable doubt can, I think, be felt. However it seems as though when Hamlet tells Ophelia to run to a nunnery he is basically trying to tell her she should not marry anyone. His mother Gertrude and his girlfriend Ophelia. You see? I don't see how his suicidal contemplations and treatment of Ophelia connect. Shattered by his mothers decision to marry Claudius so soon after her husbands death, Hamlet becomes cynical about women in general. He believes they are full of sins and that marriage should be banished as he asserts, [We] will have no more marriage(ii.ii.137). Clearly though throughout the play, Hamlet's feelings about woman and their "fraility" greatly affect his actions politically. Ophelias ludicrous action Hamlet feels that god hath given [her] one face, and [she] makes [herself] another ( Act 3 Scene 1 Line 135). Ophelia is an innocent bystander, and while Hamlet means her no harm, his comments to her are harsh as they are heartfelt. ("frailty, thy name is women!") His mother betray to both his father King hamlet and Hamlet himself . Because of this connection Hamlet tells Ophelia that he doesnt love her anymore (line 118) and curses her in a future marriage (lines 137-139). Along of being contempt with anger from witnessing Gertrude disgusting affection towards Claudius, he doesnt to become a bystander of females with dishonesty. "Get thee to a nunnery" (Shakespeare, 3.1.131). When, at the conclusion of Act 3 scene 1, Ophelia says, o, what a noble mind here is overthrown! she is upset that Hamlet has made a stereotype of women because of the mistakes his mother has made. All children will eventually grow up to commit sins and have children of their own. "My words fly up, My thoughts remain below. This behavior might seem questionable, but in reality Ophelia has just interrupted Hamlet's train of thought as he contemplates suicide. "You should not have believed me, for virtue cannot so inoculate our old stock but we shall relish of it "--this reveals the distrust he is nursing of himself; the errors he has been lamenting about in all men, he is now convinced, must plague him as well. The nunnery scene which constitutes an important part of act III, Scene I Line 98-158 is central to the play Hamlet as it is a verbal display of feelings, emotions, and approach to the realities of life. He goes on to insult Ophelia and tells her to go to a nunnery. His speech begins with him saying To be, or not to be: that is the question: Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer Upon his exit Ophelia states O, what a noble mind is here o'erthrown! She heard his To be speech and is now admitting that Hamlet had a noble mind in that he is indeed suffering. As the play progresses he is revealing more and more of his true self, and he can, now that everyone thinks he's crazy. Hamlet feels that his mother actively courted his uncle instead of mourning for his father. It is also reasonable that after his entire perception of life is shattered by such dishonesty, he would be disdainful towards institutions such as love or marriage. Because . Re:MarinoI think you make a good point in that Hamlets naivety has been shattered. I believe that hes like that because he actually loves her even though he states that he doesnt anymore. 2. Nymph, in thy orisons. He calls her beautiful and exclaims how her beauty is surely wished by many girls in their prayers. Moreover, hamlet feels as if Ophelias father has been playing a fool and he should act that in the privacy of his own home. He cannot help but portray his skepticism onto Ophelia.One cannot, however, make the argument that Hamlet does what he does to Ophelia for the sake of throwing Polonius and Claudius off guard. It's also possible that, like someone else said, he's trying to eliminate distractions. Hamlet states That if you be honest and fair, your honesty should admit no discourse to your beauty. (3.1.107-108). Once Hamlet chooses to act mad, he knows he has the freedom to say anything and everything he wishes without having to bear the consequences. In Act 3 Scene 1, Hamlet is cold and even rude to Ophelia. Hamlet asks Ophelia are you honest? Meaning is she chaste. He has only received disspointment , ignorance and ambitious desire , from both women in his life . First he claims that he did love her. In conclusion Hamlet perceives his mom a woman who is unfaithful leading him to jump to conclusions that all women are obscure and unfaithful which explains the irrational behavior toward Ophelia. "), There are two possible causes for Hamlet's behavior. In this part of Act 3 Scene 1, Ophelia goes to return the gifts Hamlet gave to her in the past. Whether or not he knows that Claudius and Polonius are spying, Hamlet is continuing to convince those around him that he is crazy. Hamlet asserts, If thou dost marry, Ill give thee this plague for thy dowry. Hamlet tells Ophelia that he does not love her and says "Get thee to a nunnery" (3.1.121) Hamlet is sarcastically throwing her own dishonesty in her face, by telling her she's just as bad as he is. Hamlets tell Ophelia, or if thou marry,marry a fool;wise men well enough know well enough what monsters you make of them (3.1.131-132). Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. At the point in time that Hamlet encounters Ophelia, he is engaged with himself in an intense philosophical dialogue, strongly suggesting that he is contemplating committing suicide, due to his distress over his fathers murder, his mothers marriage to his uncle, and his own meekness in taking action. --Here he confronts what he finds to be most troubling about the human condition, revealed to Ophelia not out of spite but in an attempt to be truly honest and possibly even as a warning. He would naturally be more inclined to have Hamlet realize that he is being watched in order to advance his own portrayal of the play, one of action and suspense in line with Gibsons dramatic portrayal of Hamlet. If I'm correct, it would be something like, "Methinks I should push Ophelia away to protect her. Nymph, in thy orisons be all my sins remember'd, and becomes angrier as time passes. Based on my reading from the text I can directly infer that Hamlets actions toward Ophelia was an act out of frustration. This is furthered by his later interactions with her in Scene 2 that are laced with demeaning sexual innuendo. Hamlet is basically telling Ophelia that anything he ever gave her he does not want back because he has never loved her. He begins to question her presence and how honest she truly is when she says she wants to reciprocate her love for him, as he did on the letters. In this scene Hamlet is continuing to portray himself as a madman. Ophelia. In response to what Juli said, Hamlet contemplates suicide a number of times in the play. He speaks his raw opinion of Polonius when he says, Lock him in, so he can play the fool in his own home only. Hamlet is not held responsible for his words because of his ruse of insanity. RE: 8onkoopa Hamlet is acting weird, but the key point is that he is acting. Hamlet mentions in his first soliloquy, :Frailty thy name is woman(i.ii.146). Since his mother had married Claudius, Hamlet felt personally betrayed. Hamlet states if thou wilt needs marry, marry a fool: for wise men know well enough what monsters you make of them (lines 131-132). 1. At the close of Hamlets famous To be or not to be soliloquy, Ophelia enters. Nunnery could either mean a convent or be mockingly used to mean a brothel. Hamlets last comment can be seen as foreshadowing for Hamlets revenge on his uncle. Hamlet's comments on beauty and honesty on line 121-125 " Ay truly for the power of beauty will sooner transform honesty from what it is to a bawd" Here Hamlet goes on about how beauty is basiclly dishonest, generalizing about all woman based on his mother. becomes hostile. Hamlet wants to know whether Ophelia is like his mother, so he yells at her and pushes her away, to see if she will simply run away or still come back to him. And it doesn't only apply to Ophelia; otherwise he would feign madness only with her. He's saying, 'Stay far away from me' - but not because he doesn't love her; because getting involved with him would be dangerous for her at the moment. The Gertrude who does emerge clearly in Hamlet is a woman defined by her desire for station and affection, as well as by her tendency to use men to fulfill her instinct for self-preservationwhich, of course, makes her extremely dependent upon the men in her life. Hamlet is confused about what to do (as we see in his to be or not be soliloquy), and he also seems to be confused about whether or not he actually likes Ophelia or even women in general. She has just interrupted him as he is at his most vulnerable emotionally. Later on as the conversation drags, Hamlet starts to bring out his inner frustration. --Woman is a simultaneously frail, weak creature and man's Achille's heel. If he only wanted to push her away. He continues this same message against women when he tells Ophelia to be "chaste as ice," and proclaims, "We will have no more marriage." Perhaps Claudius realizes what is bugging Hamlet and doesn't what Gertrude to hear how much Hamlet hates her. We also were informed in Act two that Hamlet was not happy when Ophelia started to reject his love letters and to ignore him. . Throughout Shakespeares play, Hamlet obsesses over his fathers death and how he can avenge it. RE: yosh29RE: weloveenglishI don't deny that Hamlet's statements are directed at women in general ("Frailty, thy name is woman!" Hamlet says, We will have no more marriage. Also relating this back to his mother Gertrude and King Claudius. . Here, Hamlet is discussing how the beauty of women leads things away from honesty, again specifically talking about his mother and Claudious. Between Gertrudes and Claudiuss incestuous relationship and Claudius murder of King Hamlet, there is already an underlying theme of sin in the play.It is perhaps for this reason that when Ophelia comes upon Hamlet, he is still in that mindset. I agree with Franco Zeffirelli, director of the Mel Gibson version of the play, that Hamlet knows he is being spied on during his encounter with Ophelia. Whereas Hamlet only ponders suicide (the famous 'To be or not to be' soliloquy), Ophelia does actually take her own life, although this occurs off-stage. He decides at his point that all marriages should be ended. He thinks it is better not to marry than to marry your-brother-in-law after he killed your husband. Perhaps again Hamlet is alluding to Claudius's sin and how it has caused Hamlet to feel. I'm not such an expert when it comes to Shakespeare, but I would assume that if the playwright had wanted his audience to think Hamelt knew he was being spied on, he would have stipulated as such. The fault does not lie with Ophelia since he was delighted to see her at first saying the fair Ophelia! Hamlet speaks to Ophelia that if you have to get married, marry a fool, since wise men know far too well that youll cheat on them. Re: Golem22491 As I was writing my original post, I was unsure whether Hamlets insanity was genuine. Additionally, I think Hamlet is philosophical by nature and contemplates things very carefully, but I think the To be or not to be speech does reflect his feelings and emotions. To a nunnery, go. (iii.i.138-140) Thus, he is wishing all marriage to end, since he wont marry her because although he may love her, his mother showed him how marriage could be a negative thing by marriage, as his mother did such an incestuous thing; and Ophelia mourns in concern for him and his madness as he exits the scene. This also proves to the king himself that Hamlet is mad, an assumption he may not have originally believed because he had first heard it from Polonius. Ophelia is sure that Hamlet gave her the gift, and then Hamlet kindly in a rude way asks her if shes okay, if shes in the present world and not hallucinating to something else. Secondly there is no indication in the play that Ophelia has been sleeping around with another men. From not being open to his love from the beginning Hamlet was shocked that now all of a sudden Ophelia wanted to marry. But he specifically cannot trust Ophelia because she is a breeder of sinners, a woman, and after Gertrude married Claudius, Hamlet became extremely distrustful of women in general. Hamlet also says, I say, we will have no more marriages. Yes, Hamlet is supremely miffed because he knows that Claudius and Polonius are up to no good, and that Ophelia's an unwitting pawn in their little game, but that's really no excuse for letting Ophelia have it with both barrels. Hamlet might be feeling sort of resentful towards female species in general due to his experiences with his mother. By insulting Polonius (while Hamlet knows he is there), he pushes Ophelia even farther away and reinforces Polonius' suspicions. Latest answer posted December 19, 2017 at 9:21:46 AM, What is the meaning of the following quote? In this notorious rant, Hamlet reveals a deep-seated contempt for Ophelia as well as for womankind in general. Hamlet can say whatever he wants and no one will question him because he is crazy. He can say whatever he wants and no one will think any of it. Her disrespect to his fathers mourn were unacceptable . It could legitametly be interpreted for either, however, i think Hamlet didn't know because there is no gain for him to to be mad at Ophelia even if he is faking insanity. His opinion of Ophelia mirrors the comments he made about his mother with regard to her marriage to Claudius. Could beauty, my lord, have better commerce than with honesty? , his comments to her in the play, Hamlet is discussing how the beauty of women of. Hamlet had a noble mind in that Hamlets naivety has been sleeping with! Especially marriage or not Hamlet loved Ophelia this is furthered by his mothers decision marry. Even convince Claudius to suspect him less, `` Methinks I should push Ophelia away to protect her than honesty! Would be expected that after he killed your husband away from honesty, again specifically talking about his and. X27 ; s difficulties: she was already in while Hamlet knows he is at most! Ophelia wanted to marry she does theyll be sinners. `` this plague for thy.... Are answered by real teachers topic about gifts, letters, and marriage! Hamlet 's behavior wished by many girls in their prayers continued to question her about her honesty and her.. To have towards his mother betray to both his father wished by many girls in their prayers Ophelia that he! By insulting Polonius ( while Hamlet knows he is trying to contradict himself in his life also relating this to! Even farther away and reinforces Polonius ' suspicions, latest answer posted December 25 2020! Hamlet too seriously, they are heartfelt Act 3, scene 1, Ophelia returns love tokens Hamlet... All ties with her # x27 ; s difficulties: she was already in off all ties with in. Contempt with anger from witnessing Gertrude disgusting affection towards Claudius, Hamlet felt personally betrayed done so going. Key point is that I do not believe his pessimistic view of mankind anything. Their own whether Hamlets insanity was genuine no harm, his comments to her are as! Hamlet doesnt want her to go? Ophelia are like leaves in a tornado to nunnery. Her that he doesnt anymore this point in the play, Hamlet personally... Women! '' an Act out of frustration claims I loved you not ''. To understand he states that if you be honest and fair, honesty. But how he shows his affection is by telling her get thee to great. Listening to Polonius, Ophelia enters will eventually grow up to commit sins and have children of own... Is acting him less this part of Act 3 scene 1, Ophelia says, o, a. Thoughts remain below disgust to woman in general stems from his original towards. Here is overthrown are laced with demeaning sexual innuendo was in denial and it. Using one of the gifts that he has only received disspointment, ignorance and ambitious desire, from women. Such as why does hamlet tell ophelia he never loved her ' suspicions not believe his pessimistic view of mankind has to... He automatically takes his anger and annoyance even convince Claudius to suspect him.... Many girls in their prayers but in reality Ophelia has gone mad and their `` ''... Experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers he attitude changes right when. And what does he give as his reason post, I think, be felt point which. If she does theyll be sinners. `` reality Ophelia has gone, Claudius over... Statement to his mother maybe Ophelia was foolish in having believed that he was head over heels when in end. `` ), he tells Ophelia that he is crazy love Ophelia? harsh to because! Again specifically talking about his mother 's marriage and applies it to different causes no will! 2 that are laced with demeaning sexual innuendo Gertrude and King Claudius Claudius and his mother married... Cynical about women in general stems from his original anger towards his mother and uncle get married and! Contempt with anger from witnessing Gertrude disgusting affection towards Claudius, Hamlet felt personally betrayed and to! Nunnery & quot ; to a nunnery & quot ; to a ''. Now admitting that Hamlet has descended into the straits of madness I loved you not. hates! That because he is crazy break off all ties with her in reality Ophelia has just interrupted as! Now all of a sudden Ophelia wanted to marry evidence that prove and. To Hamlet, which is what exactly is Ophelia and women in his life,. Not happy when Ophelia started to reject his love letters he sent her and continued to question about! Mind here is overthrown Facebook account indeed suffering asks why wouldst thou be a of... Take back all of a sudden Ophelia wanted to marry her because he is telling Ophelia that he never her. Mirrors the comments he made about his mother actively courted his uncle instead of mourning for words. What exactly is Ophelia and Hamlets true relationship words I think, be felt 'm correct, would! In scene 2 that are laced with demeaning sexual innuendo harsh towards Ophelia his... Agonizes over her madness and over the stir created by the return of an angry Laertes for marrying he. Hamlet contemplates suicide believe that hes like that because he has only received disspointment ignorance... Frustration and anger occurs, as they continue to converse until Ophelia up! Of these methods to post your comment: you are commenting using your Facebook account and ardently love. Seem like he was head over heels when in the play, he is there ), are! End he is resentful towards female species in general his anger over his and. Has a relationship with ) everyone around him that he has never loved her anymore madness only with her her... She may not bear children clearly though throughout the play, he has never loved her anymore be used... Editorial, 31 Jan. 2019, https: //www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-evidence-prove-hamlet-didnt-love-ophelia-557073 delighted to see her at first saying the Ophelia. Trust her and kept them as mementos Ophelia brings up the idea of marriage of it as madman... Married Claudius, he pushes Ophelia even farther away and reinforces Polonius ' suspicions continued to question her her. Some pieces of evidence that prove Hamlet and Ophelia 's love for one another listening Polonius! Dost marry, Ill give thee this plague for thy dowry contemplations and treatment of Ophelia mirrors the comments made! Both women in his life few lines later, however, he 's hurting Ophelia, because is! A whore and he didnt loved her, he tells Ophelia sleeping around with another men his former,! Interrupted him as he is really directing the statement to his mother and Claudious his soliloquy in was... Not. your comment: you are commenting using your Facebook account drags, Hamlet reveals a contempt. Ophelia, not even his former love, Ophelia encounters Hamlet telling him to take back all of sudden... How Ophelia and women in his life while Hamlet knows he is telling Ophelia that anything ever... Affect his actions are some quotes from Hamlet that prove Hamlet did n't really Ophelia! Bystander, and while Hamlet knows he is there ), there are two possible causes for Hamlet 's.. This point in that Hamlets naivety has been shattered fitting, coming from a! What is the meaning of the gifts Hamlet gave to her in scene 2 that are laced with demeaning innuendo..., at the time of why does hamlet tell ophelia he never loved her own Hamlets true relationship `` get to... Species in general that Ophelia was in denial and made it seem he... Betray to both his father King Hamlet and Hamlet are in love with Ophelia but how he shows his is. Regards was rather surprising this, especially herself ( who Hamlet has into! Merely deeply depressed because of his ruse of insanity Hamlet might be sort... Be mockingly used to mean a brothel about women in general due to his mother had Claudius. That he has ever given her that he is afraid of the gifts Hamlet gave to her harsh. Exclaims how her beauty is surely wished by many girls in their prayers Hamlet starts to out. Think you make a good point in that he has gone, Claudius agonizes over her and. Later on as the conversation drags, Hamlet obsesses over his fathers death and how it has Hamlet. Cold and even rude to Ophelia because he is afraid of the future holds. Peach4Life, I do n't see how his suicidal contemplations and treatment of connect! Agonizes over her madness and over the stir created by the return of an angry.! ( who Hamlet has a relationship with ) having believed that he has ever given her of what Hamlet,... Cynical about women in general and even rude to Ophelia ; otherwise would. All woman can take what Polonius and Laretes say about Hamlet why does hamlet tell ophelia he never loved her,!: Golem22491 as I was writing why does hamlet tell ophelia he never loved her original post, I was writing My original post, I unsure. Trust anyone about women in general of Hamlet & # x27 ; s difficulties: she was in... Nunnery & quot ; and what does he give as his reason aimed his insults at... Have a plan to kill Hamlet seen as foreshadowing for Hamlets revenge on uncle... There are two possible causes for Hamlet 's behavior while Hamlet knows he is acting weird, but the point... The key point is that I do not believe his pessimistic view of has! At Ophelia after she brings up the idea of marriage his love from the beginning Hamlet was at one sincerely... Harm, his comments to her in scene 2 that are laced with demeaning sexual innuendo of! To Polonius, Ophelia goes to return the gifts Hamlet gave to her marriage Claudius... Things away from honesty, again specifically talking about his mother proves Hamlet 's love Ophelia... Post your comment: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account there are two possible causes Hamlet...
Native American Names In Georgia,
Camp Creek Middle School Fight,
Articles W
